Joint Tenancies Made Simple: What Happens When One Tenant Wants to Leave?

If you let to couples, friends, colleagues or students, it’s potentially only a matter of time before you get that message: “One of us wants to move out…” This post explains what happens when one tenant wants to leave a joint tenancy, what you can (and can’t) do as a landlord, and the cleanest ways to replace someone without wrecking the tenancy (or your cashflow).

(Please note: this is general guidance, not legal advice. If a situation is escalating, you should seek legal support.)

First: what a “joint tenancy” really means (in plain English)

Most shared lets run on a joint tenancy, which usually means joint and several liability. In practice:

• You can legally ask any one of the tenants to cover all the rent if payments fall short.
• If one tenant disappears, the tenancy doesn’t magically become “half a tenancy”.
• The paperwork is shared too: the tenancy agreement, deposit responsibility, notice rules, and so on.

This is why you can’t just “cross out” a name and carry on like nothing has happened.

The big divider: are they in a fixed term or periodic?

This matters because your options change depending on the tenancy stage.

Important change for England from 1st May 2026: under the Renters’ Rights Act, new fixed-term assured tenancies are removed, and tenancies move to an assured periodic (“rolling”) model. Existing assured shorthold tenancies convert on 1 May 2026, so after that date you’re generally dealing with rolling tenancies rather than end-dated contracts.

So, when one tenant wants to leave, your first job is to check whether the tenancy started before 1 May 2026 and what stage it’s in right now.

If they’re in a fixed term (tenancies agreed before 1st May 2026)

A joint fixed-term tenancy can’t usually be ended early unless:

• there’s a break clause and it’s used correctly, or
• everyone agrees to end early (often via surrender), or
• everyone agrees a change (like replacing a tenant) and it’s documented properly.

Landlord tip: if you’re close to the changeover or you want less admin risk, it’s often cleaner to end and re-grant (start a new tenancy with the correct names) rather than trying to patch a fixed term with side letters and unclear deposit positions.

If they’re on a periodic tenancy (the norm after 1 May 2026)

With periodic tenancies, the tenancy “rolls” from one period to the next. One key point for landlords to understand is that one joint tenant may be able to give notice that ends the joint tenancy for everyone. That can catch you out if the remaining tenant wants to stay but hasn’t got a replacement lined up.

Post 1st May 2026 reality: because tenancies are rolling, you’re more likely to face “one tenant wants out” mid-tenancy. That makes it even more important to have a repeatable process for replacements, affordability checks, and clear written agreement on who’s responsible until the change is completed.

Your best options

Option A: Replace the leaving tenant

This is usually the least disruptive if everyone is cooperating.

What tends to work well:

• All tenants agree who’s leaving and who’s coming in
• You (or your agent) reference the replacement properly
• You document the change in writing and keep your file tidy

Shortcut that saves hassle: in many cases it’s cleaner to end the existing tenancy and start a brand-new one with the updated names (fresh signatures, clear deposit position, clear liability).

Option B: End the tenancy and re-let

This is often the simplest when:

• there’s a breakup or fall-out,
• rent sharing has already gone wobbly,
• the remaining tenant can’t afford it alone,
• you don’t like the proposed replacement.

If the tenancy ends, you can then re-let on your terms (subject to any legal requirements).

Option C: Move to a sole tenancy for the remaining tenant

This can be great when one person wants to stay and you’re happy with them, but do the checks first:

• Affordability: can they comfortably cover the rent alone?
• Guarantor (if needed): get this sorted before you sign anything new.
• Deposit handling: be crystal clear on who gets what back and when.

The landlord’s checklist: keep it smooth, keep it documented

When one tenant wants to leave, run this process (it stops arguments later):

• Get everything in writing
  • Who is leaving, proposed date, and whether anyone is serving formal notice.
• Confirm the tenancy stage
  • Fixed term or periodic? Also note the 1st May 2026 changeover for England.
• Agree the plan
  • Replace tenant / new sole tenancy / end and re-let.
• Do proper referencing for any replacement
  • Don’t skip this because “they’re a friend of the current tenant”.
• Update the deposit correctly
  • If you end and regrant, deal with the deposit and re-protect/issue paperwork as required by the scheme rules.
• Refresh your inventory/check-in position
  • If you’re changing tenants, consider a check-out/check-in style record so condition responsibility stays fair.
• Confirm rent responsibility until changeover
  • Under joint liability, rent doesn’t become “optional” because someone moved out.

How we’d handle this at Your Home Managed (and how you can too)

If you’re self-managing, the win is keeping the tone calm and the steps predictable. If you’d rather not referee a group chat meltdown, a good agent will take the heat out of it: clear notices, clear dates, clear paperwork.

And if you’re gearing up for a new let, strong marketing still matters. People searching property to rent in Streatham want clarity on bills, move-in costs, and whether the home suits sharers. The sharper your applicant checks, the fewer joint-tenancy headaches you inherit later.

If you want help managing sharers properly, from move-in to move-out, speak to a letting agent in Streatham who also acts as a property management company in Streatham (so it’s not “let it and forget it”).

What Next?

If a joint tenancy situation is brewing and you want a clean, landlord-friendly plan (replacement tenant, new agreement, deposit steps, and a solid paper trail), give our team at Your Home Managed a call.

Call 0208 125 7780 or email info@yourhomemanaged.com and we’ll talk you through the simplest route for your property and your tenants.

In the meantime, we've answered your common questions about joint tenancies.

FAQs

Can I just remove one tenant’s name from the tenancy agreement?

Usually, no - not as a quick admin tweak. Changing a joint tenancy normally needs agreement and proper documentation, and you can’t simply “take someone off” unilaterally.

If one joint tenant leaves, are they still liable for the rent?

If the joint tenancy continues, joint liability can still apply, and the remaining tenant(s) may be chased for the full rent if there’s a shortfall.

Can one joint tenant end the tenancy without the others agreeing?

In many cases, one joint tenant can give notice that ends the joint tenancy. The detail depends on the tenancy type and notice rules, so handle it carefully and get advice if you’re unsure.

Should I create a brand-new tenancy when replacing a sharer?

Often, yes, it can be the cleanest way to reset liability, paperwork, deposit handling, and inventory expectations, as long as it’s done properly.